SYNTACTICAL GUIDELINES: Design Success and Failure

Design Success

 Figure 1. The classic but timeless design of La Cornue CornuFé stove. 

The La Cornue CornuFé (Fig. 1) stove demonstrates how simple and timeless design can be effective and appealing. This kitchen appliance demonstrates a perfect symmetry that establishes a sense of balance. Although the composition is somewhat static, it clearly demonstrates the functionality of the object by having each of the elements particularly marked. The composition of the face of the CornuFé successfully demonstrates a clear perception of its intended use.  

Instead of creating contrast through decorative elements, the designer manages to stress the function of certain parts-- such as the knobs-- to identify their purpose. By implementing the same stylistically look and feel to similar features, the designer is able to group together corresponding elements. For instance, while the knobs on the oven doors look the same, they are bigger in size and different in style when compared to the knobs that correspond to the stove top. 

Design Failure 

Figure 2. Side table, designed by Simon Moorhousein. 

The side table, designed by Simon Moorhousein, demonstrates a somewhat unsuccessful approach to the Syntactical guidelines. Although the object is able to perceive its function, the balance it presents is quite ambiguous. By having all the weight rest upon the left side of the box-like structure, the design appears weak and unreliable.

By having the user question it's reliablitiy, the product is unable to fully convey wether or not it can achieve its percieved function-- to hold books, table lamps, and other objects.

Despite its failure to comply with some of the syntactical guidelines, the product by Moorhousein still remains interesting to look at and experience because of its uniqueness brought on by its asymmetrical structure and unconventional diagonals.